2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[authentic]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I think a good deal for Marmol would be... nothing. He sucks, bruh.

whatever bra

[CKW11]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I can't get anything from the CPU because it is so early. I will probably try to make some deals at the end of June. I wanted to Grandal and Venable for Duda but they weren't interested.

I'll probably call up Nieuwenhuis (Yes I looked it up) and start spot starting him until then.

Lol wow I'd definately hope they're not interested in that. If I were the Pad's GM I would seriously laugh you off the phone.

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Lol wow I'd definately hope they're not interested in that. If I were the Pad's GM I would seriously laugh you off the phone.

Ya I have to agree that's their future catcher and a solid big leaguer there for a guy who is solid but nothing special

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

And I was taking IRL about the Soriano contract and ya authentic they would have to eat a ton of that interact for most teams to bite

[Sacrafice]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Enough people have been talked about in this thread, but doing a search brings up no trade value for James Shields. I use 30 team control and Detroit wants Shields in the worst way, but want to give up Turner and Castellanos for Shields and Rodney. If I was to make a trade for Detroit what kind of stuff am I looking at to make if fair for both teams?

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Enough people have been talked about in this thread, but doing a search brings up no trade value for James Shields. I use 30 team control and Detroit wants Shields in the worst way, but want to give up Turner and Castellanos for Shields and Rodney. If I was to make a trade for Detroit what kind of stuff am I looking at to make if fair for both teams?

Exactly that Castelannos, Turner, and probably a catching prospect

Edit: try catching prospect named McCann he's a high C prospect from Arkansas add him in and see what happens

[Sacrafice]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Exactly that Castelannos, Turner, and probably a catching prospect

Edit: try catching prospect named McCann he's a high C prospect from Arkansas add him in and see what happens

McCann is a B in the OS Spring Training rosters. What I was thinking is MCcann instead of Castelannos since the Rays need a catcher prospect and not really a 3rd prospect with Longoria there along with Detroit not needing a Catcher prospect so much with Avila there. If I went that route what else would I have to add? Another B? 1B Aaron Westlake is a B and almost ML ready according to his ratings and with Prince there not really needed along with Pena's age. That seems pretty good. A & 2 B's for Shields... What do you think?

[HolyStroke3]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Sorry for continuing to blow this thread up but I'd like some opinions before I make trades.

A's get: RP Greg Holland (B), RP Louis Coleman (B)
Royals get: SP Dallas Braden (B), RP Trey Barham (C)

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Sorry for continuing to blow this thread up but I'd like some opinions before I make trades.

A's get: RP Greg Holland (B), RP Louis Coleman (B)
Royals get: SP Dallas Braden (B), RP Trey Barham (C)

A's are getting better part of the deal here unless Braden pitches how he did in his perfect game very game

[bugle987]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

McCann is a B in the OS Spring Training rosters. What I was thinking is MCcann instead of Castelannos since the Rays need a catcher prospect and not really a 3rd prospect with Longoria there along with Detroit not needing a Catcher prospect so much with Avila there. If I went that route what else would I have to add? Another B? 1B Aaron Westlake is a B and almost ML ready according to his ratings and with Prince there not really needed along with Pena's age. That seems pretty good. A & 2 B's for Shields... What do you think?

Ya I guess that could work

[grgmths1433]

can't do 4-for-1 in a single trade....plus Miller would be a waste

Chris Johnson had 2 home runs last night against the Mets. IRL

Galaxy S2

[MattGarza13]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I'm the Twins and I'm pretty much done in terms of making the playoffs.. I need to start stacking talent so I have to trade: Justin Morneau (hitting .330 2nd in hits in the AL, 19 home runs top 5 of the AL, and 52 RBIs top 5 in the AL as well) Morneau ( B potential ) is competing for the triple crown this season.

Josh Willingham ( B potential ) is deffiently expendable, hes htting .200 with 13 home runs and 38 rbis. Denard Span ( B potential ) can also be had hes 3rd in the AL in steals and the top 5 in base on balls, but is only hitting .232.. I'm also looking to move Jamey Caroll ( Maybe B potential ? ) hes hitting .250 but I believe hes first in the running for Gold Glove at SS.

Valencia ( B potential ) and Alexi Casilla ( I think B potential ) could also be moved but i'd be fine with keeping both of them ( Valencia is hitting .262 and is top 5 in doubles in the AL, and Alexi is hitting .273 fielding well and has 9 stolen bases. )

Pitchers I'd like to trade are, Carl Pavano ( B potential) 3.42 era and averages 6.8 K/9. Liriano ( B potential ) who averages 5 k/9 and has a 4.89 era. Also could trade Blackburn ( B ) and Marquis ( B ) but most likely wouldnt get anything...

Sorry its taken me a while to get back, I'm looking to ship Span because I have a plethora of minor league OFers who are looking for a chance. I like valencia but Miguel Sano is begging to be called up sooner or later leading AAA in HRs AVG and RBIs. I know hes still young.

I'm looking for pitching deffiently, relief and starting.. At 1B i have parmelee ( B ), 2nd I have rosario ( B ) coming up, SS I have Dozier ( B ) and Levi Michael( B ), 3rd I have Sano ( A ), C I have Mauer, In the OF I have Revere ( B ), Hicks ( B ), Benson ( B ), Arcia ( B )

So with all the players I'm looking to move what should I look to get, Also looking to dump Perkins.. High overall lefty with C potential, maybe package him and Caroll together for a B potential lower overall reliever?

Red Sox, Yankees, Rays, Tigers, Indians, Angles, Rangers, Philies, Braves, Cardinals, Brewers, Giants, Dodgers, Diamondbacks ( The wild card is extremely tight in both leagues. )

[rocket21]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I can't get anything from the CPU because it is so early. I will probably try to make some deals at the end of June. I wanted to Grandal and Venable for Duda but they weren't interested.

I'll probably call up Nieuwenhuis (Yes I looked it up) and start spot starting him until then.

For some reason, Venable has been impossible for me to acquire. Grandal is pretty easy, though. Some teams just have no intention of giving up certain players.

I think Grandal and Venable are worth more than just Duda alone. Try adding in another prospect (or two) that you don't care too much about and see if it goes through.

[rocket21]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Exactly that Castelannos, Turner, and probably a catching prospect

Edit: try catching prospect named McCann he's a high C prospect from Arkansas add him in and see what happens

Aren't Castelanos and Turner Detroit's two best prospects? I think I'd do that trade in a heartbeat, actually. Turner should fill out nicely over the next few years, and you can always trade Castelanos if you don't have a position for him. He should bring back more than the Shields/Rodney combination. I have done this a couple of times during my franchise - I just "pretend" it is a three-way deal, since the game won't let you do those.

[Sacrafice]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Ya I guess that could work

Thanks for helping me in the right direction. I think it's fair. 3 strong guys they will most likely be able to use for 1. Shields is 30. If he was a couple years younger I could see having to throw in the other A prospect. Also getting needs is a plus that helps tip the scales.

Aren't Castelanos and Turner Detroit's two best prospects? I think I'd do that trade in a heartbeat, actually. Turner should fill out nicely over the next few years, and you can always trade Castelanos if you don't have a position for him. He should bring back more than the Shields/Rodney combination. I have done this a couple of times during my franchise - I just "pretend" it is a three-way deal, since the game won't let you do those.

I don't control either team. Detroit has offered pretty much the same combination of trade a couple times now and I wasn't willing to just let them toss away their top 2 prospects even though it was as close to fair you will see considering it's a CPU Vs. CPU trade. Probably the best one I'll see in my franchise lol. I'm the White Sox so seeing them get Shields will only hurt me the next few years.