The batting lineup is probably right & you have it right for the positions that are really up for grabs. We are gonna have a fight for LF & CF no doubt. I've stated this before & still believe that Matt Diaz deserves a full-time chance in LF. As for CF, I think a platoon situation is what we're heading towards because no player like an Andruw Jones at that position.
I think Schafer isn't ready yet & Anderson isn't really a legit full-time CF. I can see even Brandon Jones getting some time in CF as well with also him backing up Diaz in LF. We have no player right now with the abilities even close to an Andruw in CF. Anderson can play defense well but no pop in his bat. Schafer is still too young but looks promising for the near future. Brandon Jones has some pop in his bat but not a great fielder & he's really a corner OF guy.
As for the pitching, I think you're close there as well. I think Jurrjens is a lock for a spot in the rotation for sure. I see Carlyle gone & Bennett probably back to AAA Richmond. Hampton I'm not even gonna include at this point. Chuck James certainly doesn't have a spot locked up either. He's too inconsistent & needs more pitches. That leaves probably Reyes as the best shot for another spot. I'm sure we'll see another couple minor league guys make a pitch for a spot in the rotation like Carlyle this past season.
As for the setup guy I personally see Gonzalez ahead of Moylan for that spot. He has more pitches & better stuff to be honest. I know he's a lefty but has already showed he can even be a true closer. Soriano can close but we know about his long ball problems from last year. Gonzalez could easily start the season out as our closer as well. I know he has questions with the injury from last season but if he can come back the same then I see him being our closer. Thanks!