Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

[HozAndMoose]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

Cueto and Scherzer. Both gain back the exact same amount (10%) every day.

Cueto is on top. Scherzer bottom. Cueto is just under 40% say 38% at the start of game 2. Scherzer is about mid way between 40 and 50 so lets say 44%. At the start of game 3 with an off day. Cueto is at 58% while Scherzer is at 64%. Both went up 20% in two days. Game 4 Cueto 68%. Scherzer 74%. And finally game 5 with an off day in between. Cueto 88%. Scherzer 94%. Exactly the same regeneration.

[kamackeris76]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

Everytime I come back to this thread I see logic that doesn't make sense in the decisions made in this feature. I would love to hear the reasoning behind it. I really hope they are taking note of our dissatisfaction ..... I'm sure this is something that could be patched. It's not fair that in the next set of play-off games you play you will start at a disadvantage as simmed pitchers lose less stamina. Everything about this whole issue just makes me shake my head......

[Fours]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

Casey Kelly that was on the Padres?

M.K.
Knight165

Yes, he was on my team in the Y2Y save franchise, and the first one to come to mind..

[geisterhome]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

I understand the issue, but it's not just whether they're in the MLBPA, it's whether they're included in the default rosters. An example is Casey Kelly, he's been a MLBPA member since 2012, but was generic in Y2Y transfers because he wasn't included in stock rosters.

For retired players, they just can't be included and everyone understands that, but there were too many other issues that made the value of Y2Y saves questionable such as being locked out of editing, and forced into GM contracts. There might be more issues than that, I wouldn't know because I abandoned my Y2Y franchise.

Damn didn't know that, thanks for the heads up. I find those GM goals very unrealistic, hope next year we won't be forced into them.

[Fours]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

Damn didn't know that, thanks for the heads up. I find those GM goals very unrealistic, hope next year we won't be forced into them.

As a franchise mode guy, I cringe every time I hear "GM Goals" and "Player Morale"... They're never implemented in a way that adds value.

Why would anyone want to be fired? What's next, divorce, or clinical depression decreasing your ability to make trades?

Maybe getting fired was designed to keep franchises from going too long and exposing all the flaws in pitcher progression/generated players..

[HozAndMoose]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

As a franchise mode guy, I cringe every time I hear "GM Goals" and "Player Morale"... They're never implemented in a way that adds value.

Why would anyone want to be fired? What's next, divorce, or clinical depression decreasing your ability to make trades?

Maybe getting fired was designed to keep franchises from going too long and exposing all the flaws in pitcher progression/generated players..

Except you can get fired and just get a new job

[Fours]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

Except you can get fired and just get a new job

Do a lot of guys do that? Does it add value to move on knowing the time you've spent building your team and playing games was for nothing?

If I want to switch teams for any reason, the choice should be mine, not some shallow game mechanic that resembles Mario walking into a turtle.

On a personal note, "HozAndMoose", I'm flattered that you've decided to troll so many of my posts today, aside from running a test on CPU playoff fatigue when I have time, this will be my last response to your passive aggressive replies.

[HozAndMoose]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

Do a lot of guys do that? Does it add value to move on knowing the time you've spent building your team and playing games was for nothing?

If I want to switch teams for any reason, the choice should be mine, not some shallow game mechanic that resembles Mario walking into a turtle.

On a personal note, "HozAndMoose", I'm flattered that you've decided to troll so many of my posts today, aside from running a test on CPU playoff fatigue when I have time, this will be my last response to your passive aggressive replies.

How am i trolling anything? You gave out incorrect info and i showed proof that it was wrong after you tried to make it seem like i was the one that didnt know what i was talking about. Then you say "Maybe getting fired was designed to keep franchises from going too long and exposing all the flaws in pitcher progression/generated players.." Well if that was the case they wouldnt have given the player the option to sign with another team.

[boxers]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

I actually like GM firing when implemented with reasonable goals. Some people just like the challenge of having to accomplish something without unlimited/unrealistic freedom. In fact, I could turn to you and say why does anyone play without the possibility of getting fired? There's no risk in anything you do-- essentially, you just win on your own timeframe. But everyone has their own reasons for playing.

That said, I don't why that came up in this thread. I'm no mod but maybe it's time to get back on topic.

As a franchise mode guy, I cringe every time I hear "GM Goals" and "Player Morale"... They're never implemented in a way that adds value.

Why would anyone want to be fired? What's next, divorce, or clinical depression decreasing your ability to make trades?

Maybe getting fired was designed to keep franchises from going too long and exposing all the flaws in pitcher progression/generated players..

Do a lot of guys do that? Does it add value to move on knowing the time you've spent building your team and playing games was for nothing?

If I want to switch teams for any reason, the choice should be mine, not some shallow game mechanic that resembles Mario walking into a turtle.

On a personal note, "HozAndMoose", I'm flattered that you've decided to troll so many of my posts today, aside from running a test on CPU playoff fatigue when I have time, this will be my last response to your passive aggressive replies.

[geisterhome]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

Do a lot of guys do that? Does it add value to move on knowing the time you've spent building your team and playing games was for nothing?

If I want to switch teams for any reason, the choice should be mine, not some shallow game mechanic that resembles Mario walking into a turtle.

On a personal note, "HozAndMoose", I'm flattered that you've decided to troll so many of my posts today, aside from running a test on CPU playoff fatigue when I have time, this will be my last response to your passive aggressive replies.

How am i trolling anything? You gave out incorrect info and i showed proof that it was wrong after you tried to make it seem like i was the one that didnt know what i was talking about. Then you say "Maybe getting fired was designed to keep franchises from going too long and exposing all the flaws in pitcher progression/generated players.." Well if that was the case they wouldnt have given the player the option to sign with another team.

Peace bros, don't get yourself banned or smth, obviously I'm not a mod and its not that you'd be at risk or anything but i find it too good having you around here so I'm just saying.

I actually like GM firing when implemented with reasonable goals. Some people just like the challenge of having to accomplish something without unlimited/unrealistic freedom. In fact, I could turn to you and say why does anyone play without the possibility of getting fired? There's no risk in anything you do-- essentially, you just win on your own timeframe. But everyone has their own reasons for playing.

That said, I don't why that came up in this thread. I'm no mod but maybe it's time to get back on topic.

Man I'm feeling a lot of pressure even without the risk of getting fired just cos I invested so much time and energy into a franchise, it can be quite devastating not to accomplish your own goals that I can tell you lol. That is coming from someone who is turning firing off in pretty much any game where its possible.

Alright now back on topic for real lol.

[tessl]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

As a franchise mode guy, I cringe every time I hear "GM Goals" and "Player Morale"... They're never implemented in a way that adds value.

Why would anyone want to be fired? What's next, divorce, or clinical depression decreasing your ability to make trades?

Maybe getting fired was designed to keep franchises from going too long and exposing all the flaws in pitcher progression/generated players..

What are the flaws in pitcher progression and generated players?

[NDAlum]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

They progress too fast and the league hitting numbers plummet. There's a thread about 8+ years down the line in franchise. That's a good place to read about it


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[tabarnes19_SDS]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

I just played the first two postseason series in my franchise and the cpu used a 5 man rotation in both series against me.

Went back to save after first round and simmed second and the cpu used a 4 man in the sim.

[mrsaito]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

Count me as a loyal customer who is unhappy with this 'feature'. I followed one of the links to upvote the issue but I was asked for login credentials that I didn't have.

[Fours]

Re: Starting Pitcher stamina in playoffs

Count me as a loyal customer who is unhappy with this 'feature'. I followed one of the links to upvote the issue but I was asked for login credentials that I didn't have.

The login credentials are your PSN account info. (I think.. unless I just made them the same)

The bug report will be deleted very soon. It seems they check once a week, and this latest one was more venting than helpful in any way.