Authentic stadium sounds. Get rid of the generic crap 2k puts out there, or the half hearted arena sounds that sound 'similar' - When I play in Chicago stadium, I want it to SOUND like i'm playing in Chicago stadium. Not just have the arena sounds for one game then dissapear afterwards. (Legends mode they're fine, outside of that, they are non existant)
Passing - give us the ability to bounce, lob or thread the needle etc. The passing this year has been totally flawed.
More legends/legendary teams - Self explanitory. I'd rather have this than any blacktop/team up/my player or crew mode.
Speed to matter - If I steal the ball and am already at half court ahead of everyone else using, say, ROndo, I don't expect a lumbering Centre to magically catch uo with me at the rim for a block attempt. Sort this out.
Revamped dunks/new dunk animations - Game is in desperate need of better dunk packages.
More sig layups/shots - 2k11 had me pulling off these shots quite frequently, ala Jordan's one handed hanging shot/Kobe's reverse pivot, but this year I can honestly say I've only ever seen these but a few times. Make them more accessible 2k.
Classic playoff mode - full playoff rosters for years such as 1992, 1994, 1996, 2001 etc to be fully playable as you take your favourite team of that year through to try and win the finals and re-write history.
More triple threat animations - head and shoulder fakes, shimmies, rocker steps etc. Oh and of course, have the animation of Michael Jordan palming the ball before he explodes out on that first step....
Comment