The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[_mg_]

I am the Blazers:

Portland Sends:
Greg Oden
Rudy Fernandez
2nd Round 2011

Chicago sends:
Luol Deng
Taj Gibson
1st Round Pick 2011

[thedukejr]

Quote: Originally Posted by _mg_

I am the Blazers: Portland Sends: Greg Oden Rudy Fernandez 2nd Round 2011 Chicago sends: Luol Deng Taj Gibson 1st Round Pick 2011

this is a good trade but i don't see the blazers trading oden unless they get a center in return since they are lacking in that area.

[thedukejr]

Quote: Originally Posted by ffaacc03

I like it for ATL a lot, not sure about LA ... while Smith is a good defensive player and has some length, he isnt the type of big you would need to replace Bynum ... then again, you could do a another trade further on or sign a FA to address that and round the first one ... see what big does the combo of Ratliff & Smith & Caracter can net you.

i traded for d'andre jordan from the clippers earlier in the season. he can fill in for bynum but he has a lot of developing to do.

[richyung62]

Quote: Originally Posted by _mg_

I am the Blazers: Portland Sends: Greg Oden Rudy Fernandez 2nd Round 2011 Chicago sends: Luol Deng Taj Gibson 1st Round Pick 2011

ripped them off completely, IRL this wouldnt happen, Oden cant stay healthy & the Bulls were only willing to give up a 1st rounder for Fernandez. Taj Gibson has way more upside than Oden.

[parker987]

Knicks (Me) receive:
Demar Derozan
Ed Davis

Raptors receive:
Landry Fields
Toney Douglas
Danilo Galinari

[richyung62]

Quote: Originally Posted by parker987

Knicks (Me) receive: Demar Derozan Ed Davis Raptors receive: Landry Fields Toney Douglas Danilo Galinari

pretty fair IMO.

[ewing6]

I just started a Wise Chise(dynasty rosters V 2) Im trying to trade Gilbert, I want to be fair as possible so Im gonna find teams that need a scoring SG, post the most fair deals I can find and get your opionions of them

1. Wiz Trade:
Gilbert 4 years 80 mil 81 overall SG
Josh Howard 73 SF 1 year 3 mil SF

Jazz Trade:
A. Kirilenko SF 75 17.75 mil for 1 year
CJ Miles 66 SG 1 year 3.70 mil
maybe a 2nd

They get a big scorer at the SG to put next to Dwill, they lose AK 47 but get a capable sf starter in howard, then would have gilbert and bell at SG so Miles could go. I get a solid sf on a 1 year deal, cap space eos, and I get a young sg to use, then maybe a 2nd round pick. I don't think it's too bad.

2. Wiz trade:
Gilbert 4 years 80 mil 81 overall SG
A. Gee 1 year 473k 61 overall SF (roster spot evener)
H. armstrong 1 year 853k 61 overall C

Pacers Trade;
Mike Dunleavy 71 overall SG 1 year 10.56 mil
Paul George 65 overall sf 2 years 4.64 mil(D+ pot on this roster so its not like hes studly)
Jeff Foster 66 overall C 1 year 6.66 mil

They get a big time scoring SG to go with the Granger/Collison/Hibbert core. They can trade Mike since they would have Gilbert and Rush. They get a younger cheaper pretty much as good backup c. Gee is there to even up the roster spots. I get a SG and a backup center with expiring deals and a young SF stuck behind Granger and comp. Not as sure if this is fair.

Any thoughts? Raps had the contracts to matchup, but I don't think they want Gilbert at this time while rebuilding and the Knicks and Nets have the things also, but do I ruin there runs at Melo. Bulls were a fit, but didnt have the contracts to even it out, could bring a 3rd team into it to spar this perhaps. Any thoughts here, or anything Im missing

[J-Clutch1]

Quote: Originally Posted by ewing6

I just started a Wise Chise(dynasty rosters V 2) Im trying to trade Gilbert, I want to be fair as possible so Im gonna find teams that need a scoring SG, post the most fair deals I can find and get your opionions of them 1. Wiz Trade: Gilbert 4 years 80 mil 81 overall SG Josh Howard 73 SF 1 year 3 mil SF Jazz Trade: A. Kirilenko SF 75 17.75 mil for 1 year CJ Miles 66 SG 1 year 3.70 mil maybe a 2nd They get a big scorer at the SG to put next to Dwill, they lose AK 47 but get a capable sf starter in howard, then would have gilbert and bell at SG so Miles could go. I get a solid sf on a 1 year deal, cap space eos, and I get a young sg to use, then maybe a 2nd round pick. I don't think it's too bad. 2. Wiz trade: Gilbert 4 years 80 mil 81 overall SG A. Gee 1 year 473k 61 overall SF (roster spot evener) H. armstrong 1 year 853k 61 overall C Pacers Trade; Mike Dunleavy 71 overall SG 1 year 10.56 mil Paul George 65 overall sf 2 years 4.64 mil(D+ pot on this roster so its not like hes studly) Jeff Foster 66 overall C 1 year 6.66 mil They get a big time scoring SG to go with the Granger/Collison/Hibbert core. They can trade Mike since they would have Gilbert and Rush. They get a younger cheaper pretty much as good backup c. Gee is there to even up the roster spots. I get a SG and a backup center with expiring deals and a young SF stuck behind Granger and comp. Not as sure if this is fair. Any thoughts? Raps had the contracts to matchup, but I don't think they want Gilbert at this time while rebuilding and the Knicks and Nets have the things also, but do I ruin there runs at Melo. Bulls were a fit, but didnt have the contracts to even it out, could bring a 3rd team into it to spar this perhaps. Any thoughts here, or anything Im missing

Both are fine. I say do the first one.