2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[UofO Ducks]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I am the Pirates and the Tigers offered me this:

Pirates Get
SP Carlos Martinez
RF Oscar Taveras
3B Nick Castellanos

Pirates Give Up
CP Joel Hanrahan

I really want to accept. But than I need a new closer. Any suggestions on a trade for a guy to take Hanrahan's spot.

You have EVAN MEEK. He could close games. Yeah joel zumya is a good one.

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

What do you think the Mets would have to give up to get Castro from the Cubs?

2 A prospects

[brett the jet favre]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

What do you think the Mets would have to give up to get Castro from the Cubs?

They wouldnt trade him..

[redskins24]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

what do yall think of this trade should i do it im in my nats franchise ok im using knights roster im going to give up.......... LF mike morse who is age 29 and is about to go down hill because of his age...stats are overall A contact C power B fielding F speed D potential A FOR minor league CF BUBBA STARLING age 19 POTENTIAL A and minor league player 3B CHESLOR CUTHBERT age 19 POTENTIAL A and minor league player RF WILL MYERS age 21 POTENTIAL A ................ im rebuilding this team with young talent so tell me what you think

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

what do yall think of this trade should i do it im in my nats franchise ok im using knights roster im going to give up.......... LF mike morse who is age 29 and is about to go down hill because of his age...stats are overall A contact C power B fielding F speed D potential A FOR minor league CF BUBBA STARLING age 19 POTENTIAL A and minor league player 3B CHESLOR CUTHBERT age 19 POTENTIAL A and minor league player RF WILL MYERS age 21 POTENTIAL A ................ im rebuilding this team with young talent so tell me what you think

horrible trade......ur robbing KC blind

[redskins24]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

horrible trade......ur robbing KC blind

i look at it this way yes i did rob them blind but they went for it and it was my first ever minor league tradebut look this way the 3B men wll come when zimmermen calls it quits he getin age and the out field player will replace worth he is in age i need young talent that's will replace these big rolls

[hawks223]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

what do yall think of this trade should i do it im in my nats franchise ok im using knights roster im going to give up.......... LF mike morse who is age 29 and is about to go down hill because of his age...stats are overall A contact C power B fielding F speed D potential A FOR minor league CF BUBBA STARLING age 19 POTENTIAL A and minor league player 3B CHESLOR CUTHBERT age 19 POTENTIAL A and minor league player RF WILL MYERS age 21 POTENTIAL A ................ im rebuilding this team with young talent so tell me what you think

You could easily get Starling for Morse the guy is completely unproven, and why do you want Cuthbert when you have Anthony Rendon? No way 3 A prospects for Mike Morse.

[hawks223]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I'm the Twins.

Really looking to get a ace type pitcher on my team.

I was thinking Johan Santana. The computer would accept Liriano and Perkins. Not sure I want to give up Perkins. Any thoughts?

Can you really call Santana a "Ace" anymore? He hasn't been close to as good since leaving Minnesota. I'd say he's a high level #2 at this point.

[chicubsfan20]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

David Robertson from the Yanks? although they'd have no use for Byrd....they'd want a ready, major-league player in return

Maybe a DH if I give them Soriano? I think I may go that route too, in invent I can find a way to unload Dempster, Soto, and even LaHair to get me a young OF to bring in to round of my potential OF combo of Jackson, Szczur, and the new prospect.

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Maybe a DH if I give them Soriano? I think I may go that route too, in invent I can find a way to unload Dempster, Soto, and even LaHair to get me a young OF to bring in to round of my potential OF combo of Jackson, Szczur, and the new prospect.

the offense is the least of the Yankees problem....now if u had a proven end of the rotation starter.......

[redskins24]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

You could easily get Starling for Morse the guy is completely unproven, and why do you want Cuthbert when you have Anthony Rendon? No way 3 A prospects for Mike Morse.

i did get all 3 they went with it and i took cuthbert because he will be my 3B and ANTHONY RENDON can play 2B for his second position........................ so that gives me A prospects for the following positions 3B 2B CF RF and LF is bryce harpper so my outfield will be stacked in a few years

[AUTiger1]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Here is a trade I made in my Braves franchise.

I got Alex Gordon, Greg Holland and Tim Collins from the Royals for Michael Bourn, Randall Delgado and Adam Russell.

Thoughts?

[ScouserHUN]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Hi there!

I have some selection headache, and I'm looking for your help.

I'm with the RedSox, just started spring training. I have signed Oswalt and Soler, but that's all. My problem is selecting the 5th starter and what shoul I do with the rest?

I have the 1,2,3,4 starters set in stone:

1. Lester
2. Beckett
3. Buchholz
4. Oswalt

After them I have:

Bard (I'm not decided If he will be a starter or not)
DiceK
Lackey

So should I pick DiceK or Lackey over Bard, and I put Bard back to the bullpen. Or should I pick Bard, but what will I do with Lackey and DiceK then?

Of course everything depends on the performances in spring training (I plan to play 3/4 of spring training).

[Dogslax41]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I am the Reds and looking to get Murphy from the Mets. There was some talk this offseason about them being interested in Bailey but now that the season is here it looks like they are going to lean on him to start and they are really short in the middle infield. Do you think I could reasonably get him? I was thinking Bailey straight up or packaging him with Didi but with Tejada I don't think they would value a high prospect SS.

Thoughts?

[Bengals28]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

In my Marlins chise I'm 1-5. I refuse to go below all-star, kind of a personal challenge. Anyways my dilemma is Heath Bell. I would be 3-3 instead of 1-5 if not for him being 0/2 in save opportunities with an ERA over 100 yes, 100. Should I hold on and give him more chances? I know it's VERY early and the Marlins just paid him all that money. A couple more performances like that though and I'll need a new closer.