MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

[themoneyteam1212]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

What would it take to get archer to the Giants. Using osm rosters

I traded beach a top 50 prospect and another SP with A ponential and an outfielder with A potential. That enough for him?

[pickle2002]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

Charlie 'Chuck Nazty' Blackmon, to return home to the ATL.

Doable?

I got 172.8 mil surplus for Blackmon (wasn’t expecting that much!). Considering Acuna is worth 81.4 mil, I’m don’t think you can get Blackmon without giving up Acuna unless, you give up most of your farm (pretty much everyone besides Acuna).

I would wait until mrserendipity, bard, yankee or others have their say.

[jdiaz891]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

I got 172.8 mil surplus for Blackmon (wasn’t expecting that much!). Considering Acuna is worth 81.4 mil, I’m don’t think you can get Blackmon without giving up Acuna unless, you give up most of your farm (pretty much everyone besides Acuna).

I would wait until mrserendipity, bard, yankee or others have their say.

Im getting between 95.76 mil and 126.76 mil depending on if the options are picked up by him. I might be doing something wrong but either way he is a very valuable player so i think Rockies would be looking for a couple of top 50 prospects.

But like pickle2002 said, Id wait for those guys.

[pickle2002]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

Im getting between 95.76 mil and 126.76 mil depending on if the options are picked up by him. I might be doing something wrong but either way he is a very valuable player so i think Rockies would be looking for a couple of top 50 prospects.

But like pickle2002 said, Id wait for those guys.

I was using the 6-3-1 method that mrserendipity posted last page. But I get the 126 mil that you got when I use his average war from the last 3 years.

There is a pretty big difference in value from 126 mil to 172 mil so I’m not sure which method to use here. Using the 126 mil you’ll be able to get him without acuna.

[Buccosback]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

Looking to acquire Manny Machado to play SS for my Pirates. Would Shane Baz, Steven Jennings & Kevin Newman cut it? If that's not enough, would replacing Jennings with Ke'Bryan Hayes work?

Thanks

Replace Steven Jennings with another high B potential player. Idk the values just what i think the value would be given the expiration of Machado's contract.

What do you think of this deal cause i'm also doing the pirates.

Pit Acquires:
Shohei Ohtani
Ryan Schimpf
Albert Pujols

LAA Acquires:
Starling Marte
Shane Baz
George Kontos
Chad Kuhl
Kevin Newman
Brandon Phillips

[MrSerendipity]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

162M is accurate on Blackmon. Crazy, right? Dude has been playing out of his mind the last two years.

This is what a deal with Atlanta would look like.

COL REC: Acuna | Wright | Soroka | Fried
ATL REC: Blackmon | Lottery Pitcher

For the sake of fun though, lets say Atlanta really likes Blackmon but simply can't see themselves parting with Acuna. Lets play with a three way trade that will probably have my boys Bard and Yankee yelling "WTF" in the morning.

ATL REC: Charlie Blackmon | Justin Bour
COL REC: Freddie Freeman | JT Realmuto | Mike Soroka
MIA REC: Brendan Rodgers | Kyle Wright | Austin Riley | Max Fried

Atlanta: This gives Atlanta an Outfield of Acuna, Blackmon and Inciarte which is a pretty huge upgrade over Markakis. They lose Freeman but get a pretty underrated first basemen in Justin Bour. You get taxed a bit for inner-division and have to include Fried in the deal to Miami.

Colorado: Interestingly enough, I think Colorado ends up with 5M less in surplus than they give up but what a deal this is for them. Freeman would be outstanding in Colorado. They get a highly coveted catcher in Realmuto as well. Blackmon is a loss for sure but they've already started working Dahl into the mix and he simply gets the bump into the starting lineup full-time with this move. Tapia fills the fourth outfielder spot. Then they add a Top 35 pitcher in the deal. Losing Rodgers isn't ideal but I'm sure they would be fine rolling out an infield of Freeman, LeMahieu, Story and Arenado.

Miami: A team that isn't anywhere close to competing deals two pieces they likely intend to move regardless and in return get one Top 25 Position Prospect, a Top 50 Pitching Prospect, a Top 100 Pitching Prospect and a Top 100 Position Prospect. I can't imagine they would have any issue swinging this deal from their side.

I think the biggest thing is the swapping of Blackmon and Freeman but so long as Atlanta is good with Bour, I think this is a really interesting three-way deal.

[Smooth Pancakes]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

162M is accurate on Blackmon. Crazy, right? Dude has been playing out of his mind the last two years.

This is what a deal with Atlanta would look like.

COL REC: Acuna | Wright | Soroka | Fried
ATL REC: Blackmon | Lottery Pitcher

For the sake of fun though, lets say Atlanta really likes Blackmon but simply can't see themselves parting with Acuna. Lets play with a three way trade that will probably have my boys Bard and Yankee yelling "WTF" in the morning.

ATL REC: Charlie Blackmon | Justin Bour
COL REC: Freddie Freeman | JT Realmuto | Mike Soroka
MIA REC: Brendan Rodgers | Kyle Wright | Austin Riley | Max Fried

Atlanta: This gives Atlanta an Outfield of Acuna, Blackmon and Inciarte which is a pretty huge upgrade over Markakis. They lose Freeman but get a pretty underrated first basemen in Justin Bour. You get taxed a bit for inner-division and have to include Fried in the deal to Miami.

Colorado: Interestingly enough, I think Colorado ends up with 5M less in surplus than they give up but what a deal this is for them. Freeman would be outstanding in Colorado. They get a highly coveted catcher in Realmuto as well. Blackmon is a loss for sure but they've already started working Dahl into the mix and he simply gets the bump into the starting lineup full-time with this move. Tapia fills the fourth outfielder spot. Then they add a Top 35 pitcher in the deal. Losing Rodgers isn't ideal but I'm sure they would be fine rolling out an infield of Freeman, LeMahieu, Story and Arenado.

Miami: A team that isn't anywhere close to competing deals two pieces they likely intend to move regardless and in return get one Top 25 Position Prospect, a Top 50 Pitching Prospect, a Top 100 Pitching Prospect and a Top 100 Position Prospect. I can't imagine they would have any issue swinging this deal from their side.

I think the biggest thing is the swapping of Blackmon and Freeman but so long as Atlanta is good with Bour, I think this is a really interesting three-way deal.

Hmm, I'm keeping both of these in mind on the chance I decide to take advantage of Blackmon's insane value and pawn him off in return for a treasure trove.

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

[Kahler77]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

They would be VERY stupid and incompetent to do so.

Keep Miggy, he is a Hall of Famer. Trade Fulmer solo so you can get a hell of a package for him.

Sent from my SM-G935V using Tapatalk

Would a team like the Yankees make a trade for Fulmer as they are in contention and are one of the few teams in a position to deal away Fulmer's Value in prospects and still have top 100 guys left.

[PGHFan412]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

Replace Steven Jennings with another high B potential player. Idk the values just what i think the value would be given the expiration of Machado's contract.

What do you think of this deal cause i'm also doing the pirates.

Pit Acquires:
Shohei Ohtani
Ryan Schimpf
Albert Pujols

LAA Acquires:
Starling Marte
Shane Baz
George Kontos
Chad Kuhl
Kevin Newman
Brandon Phillips

I appreciate the feedback. I tend to agree with the others on this thread that the Angles would never do this, however i do believe it is a fair swap, especially with you taking on the Pujols contract

[MrSerendipity]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

Would a team like the Yankees make a trade for Fulmer as they are in contention and are one of the few teams in a position to deal away Fulmer's Value in prospects and still have top 100 guys left.

I could see New York swinging a deal for Fulmer. As it would with any team, it is going to hurt.

NYY REC: Michael Fulmer | Low Lottery Pitcher
DET REC: Gleyber Torres | Estevan Florial | Justus Sheffield | Chance Adams

EDIT: Adding in a low lottery pitcher going back to New York as a 1 for 4 trade is technically not possible in The Show.

[steelersd26]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

I could see New York swinging a deal for Fulmer. As it would with any team, it is going to hurt.

NYY REC: Michael Fulmer | Low Lottery Pitcher
DET REC: Gleyber Torres | Estevan Florial | Justus Sheffield | Chance Adams

EDIT: Adding in a low lottery pitcher going back to New York as a 1 for 4 trade is technically not possible in The Show.

My only comment about the Yankees trades involving Torres is that I don't believe they're going to give him up in any deal, especially given how close he is to making his Major League Debut.

[MrSerendipity]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

My only comment about the Yankees trades involving Torres is that I don't believe they're going to give him up in any deal, especially given how close he is to making his Major League Debut.

I don't necessarily disagree with that. With that said, it is the only way they get Fulmer. With guys like Manny Machado, DJ LeMahieu, Brian Dozier and etc. coming on the market this off-season, they can fill that middle infield gap with a very solid player.

[NateNY]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

Can someone help me please? I’m about a month away from the trade deadline and I need to know if this trade can go though since I don’t know how to find the surplus value of prospects. I’m the Mets.

1B Peter Alonso
SS Andres Gimenez
SP Marcus Molina
For
2B Scooter Gennett

[BigOscar]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

In my save the Yankees have lost Gary Sanchez for the season, Severino is out until the final month and Sabbathia is declining at a rapid rate. I'm completely out of it with the Rays and was thinking of trading them Wilson Ramos and Nathan Eovaldi to get the money off my payroll and fill their gaps.

Eovaldi has pitched well since returning from injury, with an ERA of around 3.8, while Ramos was an all star with pretty solid numbers (.270/13 HR)

Do I get anything in return? or is the maybe $6m in savings my main benefit? I know I don't get anything special, but what sort of longshot am I looking at, if the deal makes sense at all?

[Yankees247]

Re: MLB 18 The Show Trade Discussion

I could see New York swinging a deal for Fulmer. As it would with any team, it is going to hurt.

NYY REC: Michael Fulmer | Low Lottery Pitcher
DET REC: Gleyber Torres | Estevan Florial | Justus Sheffield | Chance Adams

EDIT: Adding in a low lottery pitcher going back to New York as a 1 for 4 trade is technically not possible in The Show.

Value wise I get it but no way it would happen IRL.