It's only a one game sample size, plus it was in play now, not a franchise game.
I played my first franchise game after the patch with 11 seconds remaining and needed a TD to win.
Rodgers to Montgomery on a 60 fly pattern, single coverage.
Did you adjust penalty sliders here and there, or just straight up all-Pro? Heck, for the first half, Cutler was 90% vs the Packers. He ended up throwing an Int and missing several times in the second half with blitzes coming at him.
Cutler ended up at 63% and Rodgers ended up at 68%.
I don't count Play Now games as realistic stat gathering games, slider makers will tell you the same thing.