What rating are you most annoyed at?

[TB5XSBW]

Quote: Originally Posted by Madden08PCgmr

You've confused the Packers with Rodgers. He's the 3rd highest rated active post-season passer, within 1 point and change from retaking the top spot, which he held almost his entire career. Next we have the splits; QB rating with score tied Rodgers - 106.0 Brady - 98.5 QB rating, tied under 4:00 to go Rodgers - 93.8 Brady - 58.6 QB rating, tied under 2:00 to go Rodgers - 114.8 Brady - 68.3 QB rating in losses Rodgers - 85.9 Brady - 73.9 QB rating when trailing Rodgers - 98.0 Brady - 90.8 QB rating, trailing under 4:00 to go Brady - 88.6 Rodgers - 82.9 QB rating, trailing under 2:00 to go Brady - 83.4 Rodgers - 73.7 .. so Rodgers chokes, huh? Sorry, I don't see it.

Yes, he chokes massively in key situations in big games. Choking doesn't prevent one from padding his stats against poor teams or in garbage time. Peyton Manning was the master of this, too.

Comparing playoff QB rating, or any other postseason stat between the two, is absurd. Rodgers gets to play on wildcard weekend almost every year, against some of the worst teams in the league, meanwhile Brady is always in the AFCCG and SB against the top teams. He still wins those games, and has a ridiculous record against top ranked defenses in the postseason - something like 5-1 or 6-1. He has a ton of GWD in big games as well, and holds all of the postseason cumulative and single game records. There's no comparison when it comes to each guy's clutchness.

Quote:

There is no chance he's a real threat to Bradys legacy. It doesn't look like the Packers will win another Super Bowl, let alone 2 or 3.

Correct.

[TB5XSBW]

Quote: Originally Posted by briz1046

Umm ? The fact that there is even a debate here disproves that .... it fairly obviously ISN'T accepted by everybody Please stop mistaking facts with YOUR OPINION it gets tiresome

There's no one debating this. It's a widely accepted fact amongst experts, analysts, former & current players, and even amongst all of you. The only place where you will see people claiming to believe otherwise is on internet forums, but these people are only trying to be edgy by trolling. Even they strongly believe that Brady is the GOAT.

[TB5XSBW]

Quote: Originally Posted by underdog13

As a Bears fan, I really wish the above statement was true. But it's so far from reality it's not funny. Sent from my SM-G965U using Tapatalk

It's impossible for anyone to choke against the Bears. That's why you've never seen it.

[TB5XSBW]

Quote: Originally Posted by stinkubus

Rodgers has been keeping a roster that has Browns level talent, aside from him, competitive.

Stop trolling.

[Madden08PCgmr]

Quote: Originally Posted by TB5XSBW

Yes, he chokes massively in key situations in big games. Choking doesn't prevent one from padding his stats against poor teams or in garbage time. Peyton Manning was the master of this, too.

As the splits show, that is flat out nonsense. But you can believe whatever you want.

I'd post the horrendous stats the Packers defense is responsible for in the post-season, but it wouldn't matter to you.

[ncbravesfan]

Personally, I was annoyed at Eli Manning's rating. Hey, I know he is on the downside of his career, but to be the 35th ranked QB in the league? Not saying he is anywhere near a top 10 QB, but with a better OL, more offensive weapons and a head coach who is not a buffoon, I would not be surprised to see him somewhere in the 15-20 range.


He certainly deserves to be rated better than guys who haven't thrown an NFL pass (Rosen, Mayfield, Jackson), guys who haven't established themselves (Mahomes), guys who aren't even projected to be starters (Bridgewater), or guys who have shown some flashes but may not even end up being their team's starter by season's end (McCown, Taylor, Keenum).

[roadman]

Only 1 person trolling, same person that enjoys kicking up the dust with pc vs console and console vs console stuff.

And anything Brady and is miffed any other QB comes up in the discussion.

[TB5XSBW]

Quote: Originally Posted by Madden08PCgmr

As the splits show, that is flat out nonsense. But you can believe whatever you want. I'd post the horrendous stats the Packers defense is responsible for in the post-season, but it wouldn't matter to you.

The splits include games where Rodgers pads his stats in garbage time, as his team is losing big. Sorry, but that doesn't impress me.

Name some memorable 4th quarter performances from him. I guarantee you that you can't come up with anything other than literally only two passes in two games.