Slider Update Log
12/15/18 - Here is Version 21.
Spent a bit of time combing through feedback, and validating the concerns. Thankfully not many, but just a couple adjustments needed to really calm Version 20 down. I think I've done this now by not having to modify penalty sliders and not modifying threshold. Yet, the coverage is tighter, the run game less explosive and the animations are good, if not better, than before.
With that said here are the changes:
Pass Blocking: 48/48 (from 52/52)
Version 21: The issue with PBL is that it not only affects the pass game, but it also affects the run game. I was trying to figure out why the run game still felt sticky and a bit easy on both sides. Tackle value was a possibility, but that didn't help the disengagement of the OL/DL. Dropping this value down is absolutely key to this set, and it has now allowed the proper amount of disengage for both the passing and run game.
WR Catch: 38/38 (from 42/42)
Version 21: I was needing to find a way to re-sync the pass coverage due to the lowering of PBL. So, adjusting the WRC was one of the last things I had thought about as a solution. Pleasantly surprised with how much better the interaction is between a DB/WR now. Rarely stopping on routes except for the occasional poor match-up in a playaction. The best part is the drop counts have not changed, and catches in traffic can still happen, not to mention the occasional diving catch. Quite content here.
Pass Defense Reaction Time: 48/48 (from 40/40)
Version 21: The good thing is this value plays true to its number, but is still based on what the INT and PCV values are, not to mention the PBL + WRC. Good mix of attempts at picks and also swats. Found myself in replay quite a lot to see the defender's reactions.
*Note, there are no changes to Special Teams or Penalty slider values.*
Game Settings
If you provide feedback, please advise of any modifications you have done from this OP set. Also, please include if you are providing feedback on All-Madden or All-Pro. Thank you!
Skill Level: All-Pro or All-Madden
Rosters: EA Default (Active or Preseason)
Auto-subs: Default
Game Speed: Normal
Game Style: Simulation
Quarter Length: 9 minutes
Accelerated Clock: Off
Gameplay Helpers
Ball Carrier Special Move: Manual
Defensive Auto Strafe: Off
Defensive Ball Hawk: Off
Defensive Heat Seeker Assist: Off
Defensive Switch Assist: Off
Game Options
Injuries: 13
No changes. Kudos to Tommy again for these as it allows such a nice balance of entire game injuries, temporary injuries, different severity, just good overall mixture.
Fatigue: 50
No changes. The stamina gauge doesn't deplete with the slow down animation anymore, so I'm much happier with seeing this to come back up.
Min Player Threshold: 15
No changes. Dropped this down further from 30, and found a nice spot with 15. Paired up with the PBL value and PCV, this really made a big difference in separating players further, and releasing them of their forcefield chains.
Player/CPU Skill Settings
*Community PC file: "Matt10V21" (pending, tbd)
*Community PS4 file: "Matt10V21" (pending, hosted by Escobar)
QB Accuracy: 40/40 All-Pro & All-Madden
No changes. I've kept the 40 for both AP and AM here. The reason being is that I want more risks being taken by the QB in the harder difficulty. The QBA value is just enough that not every pass is a floater to the sideline, and has enough zip onto it when there is a sure pass. From there it is a matter of whether the QB is being pressured and how they deal with it paired with their ratings.
Pass Blocking: 48/48
Version 21: The issue with PBL is that it not only affects the pass game, but it also affects the run game. I was trying to figure out why the run game still felt sticky and a bit easy on both sides. Tackle value was a possibility, but that didn't help the disengagement of the OL/DL. Dropping this value down is absolutely key to this set, and it has now allowed the proper amount of disengage for both the passing and run game.
WR Catch: 38/38
Version 21: I was needing to find a way to re-sync the pass coverage due to the lowering of PBL. So, adjusting the WRC was one of the last things I had thought about as a solution. Pleasantly surprised with how much better the interaction is between a DB/WR now. Rarely stopping on routes except for the occasional poor match-up in a playaction. The best part is the drop counts have not changed, and catches in traffic can still happen, not to mention the occasional diving catch. Quite content here.
Run Blocking: 50/50
No changes. The CPU no longer needs an advantage here. They do quite well to find gaps, and stick to their game. I found it interesting how post patch it is much harder to defend the run in some situations, but lowering RBL was not an option as that creates poor angles taken by the pulling guards, etc versus actually legit being beaten across the line.
Fumbles: 49/49
No changes. Actually had to drop this down because the running backs would cut aross the grain unnecessarily at times. They are not avoiding the gap by any means, but they were also trying to get to an OL blocking for them versus going north/south when necesary with it at 50 for some reason.
Pass Defense Reaction Time: 48/48
Version 21: The good thing is this value plays true to its number, but is still based on what the INT and PCV values are, not to mention the PBL + WRC. Good mix of attempts at picks and also swats. Found myself in replay quite a lot to see the defender's reactions.
Interceptions: 35/35
No changes. Dropped this one a bit from 40 because defenders were choosing the intercept animation instead of deflecting passes.
Pass Coverage: 50/50
No changes. This is the normalized value. I had kept it at 40 and lower for a while, but the lower threshold needs to have a little love to it, but not so much that it is mirroring the routes. I found it interesting that in previous patches this value was reversed, but am finding that it fairly true, but it also does not have as big of an impact this patch update compared to ones before. I believe this is because the zone improvement helps an overall coverage standpoint, but when paired with a higher, sticky, threshold, it makes animations too uniform, which causes the logic of the play to fall by the wayside.
Tackling: 38/38
No changes. Still good. The higher tackles brought in solid tackle animations, but it became easily 1v1 drills, and the defender won each time. The under 40 tackle value brings in such better animations from missed tackles, to wrap up tackles, to gangtackling, momentum forward/backward tackles.
Special Teams
*note separate values from User/CPU can be changed in Main Menu, however there is no proof that the values import as separate in a franchise*
FG Power: 55/55
I've said it before, but I like that "oomph!" in the kick. This not only allows that to happen, but it allows the accuracy value to be modified under 50 as well so there are no random driven soccer kicks into the crossbar.
FG Accuracy: 48/50
Bumped this up for the CPU because seen 90+ kpw kickers come up well short and bar level, just wasn't realistic. Kept the FG power because still need that oomph.
Punt Power: 48/48
May have mentioned it before, but this value is super sensitive. There is a 10-yard glitch though that happens when punting into the wind, so just be on the lookout with those. However, I did want less powered punts into the endzone that would get the punter fired on the spot if he did once in a game, let alone the multiple times this game allows it.
Punt Accuracy: 44/44
Version 20 Dropped this one a tad more because way too much perfect punts by both user and CPU. Have to force myself to make a bad punt sometimes. The amount of back bouncing is crazy.
Kickoff Power: 48/48
Good value here to get the ball struck perfectly through the endzone, or come up short of the goal-line.
Penalties
All Penalties Set to Default 50 or ON
As I said, I have enjoyed modifying the gameplay by using the power of the penalty sliders with a zero threshold, but that became a bit of a balancing act that got a bit over my head and patience. It skewed feedback because not only was I relying on feedback of the gameplay sliders, I also needed to receive confirmation that the penalty values were also adhered to. This became a sense of second guessing and inconsistency as a result. I believe having these as default are good for the set, but definitely adjust them as you see fit.